A blood stain discovered on grownup floral-design leggings found by Gardaí on the residence of homicide accused Karen Harrington (37) matched the DNA profile of Santina Cawley (2).
he revelation got here as a Central Prison Courtroom homicide trial was instructed that the 2 yr outdated was discovered to have a complete of 53 separate accidents.
Clumps of hair discovered within the condominium of Karen Harrington had been additionally discovered to have come from Santina Cawley.
The trial additionally heard that the toddler’s father, Michael Cawley (37), confronted homicide accused Karen Harrington on the scene in entrance of gardaí and shouted that she was “a monster”.
Harrington of Lakelands Crescent, Mahon, Cork, has pleaded not responsible to the homicide of the 2 yr outdated at a Central Prison Courtroom trial earlier than Mr Justice Michael MacGrath and a jury of seven males and 4 girls.
Santina was discovered mendacity bare on a unclean blanket with important accidents at 26 Elderwood Park off the Boreenamanna Street in Cork metropolis at 5am on July 5, 2019.
Karen Harrington lived within the flat on the time.
The little woman was found badly injured when her father, Michael Cawley, returned to his then-girlfriend’s flat having left the property two hours earlier at 3am to stroll alone into Cork metropolis centre in a bid to find his Limerick cousin.
Regardless of determined efforts by docs and paramedics to stabilise the situation of the little woman, she was pronounced useless a short while after being rushed to Cork College Hospital (CUH).
Sean Gillane SC, for the State, mentioned that little Santina’s accidents couldn’t have been suffered within the regular tough and tumble of kid play.
A publish mortem examination was performed at CUH which discovered Santina had sustained poly trauma and “devastating accidents with no probability of restoration.”
Forensic Science Eire (FSI) knowledgeable Dr Sibeal Waldron instructed the seventh day of the trial that she performed DNA checks on varied blood stains recognized by gardaí on the Elderwood condominium.
A pair of grownup floral-style leggings was found by gardaí in a again bed room at Karen Harrington’s condominium.
The trousers confirmed indicators of heavy blood-staining.
On the higher left part of the leggings – which had been pulled inside out – Dr Waldron mentioned the blood stain matched the DNA profile obtained of Santina Cawley.
Different blood stains on the garment matched the profile of Karen Harrington.
A pink kid’s T-shirt was additionally examined with blood stains discovered on the collar and shoulder.
One blood stain returned a blended DNA pattern profile.
Dr Waldron mentioned it was “one thousand million to 1” instances extra probably that the blended DNA pattern was from Santina Cawley and Karen Harrington reasonably than Santina Cawley and unknown others.
She additionally mentioned that blood staining analysed from the kitchen of the condominium matched the DNA of Karen Harrington.
An evaluation of shorts, T-shirt and runners taken from Santina’s father, Michael Cawley, returned no hint of blood.
Forensic scientist Dr Jennifer Ryan confirmed that an evaluation of the clumps of hair found within the condominium discovered that they had been pulled from the top.
A DNA evaluation indicated the hair clump was from Santina.
CUH paediatric advisor Professor Deirdre Murray pronounced the kid useless at 9.20am with the little woman having suffered devastating accidents from which there was no hope of restoration.
The little woman died minutes after she was positioned by docs and nurses into the arms of her mom, Bridget, when all life-saving procedures had been ceased.
Prof Murray had rushed at 6.30am to the CUH emergency division to deal with the little woman.
In written proof to the trial, learn out by Mr Gillane, Prof Murray mentioned Santina was discovered with “a number of bruises (together with on the) brow, bruises to the chest, a swollen leg, a femur fracture (historic)…and her pupils had been mounted and dilated indicating a extreme mind harm.”
Detective Garda Stephen Dennehy, who was the crime scene supervisor appointed to the case, mentioned gardaí had been knowledgeable Santina had suffered 49 exterior accidents and 4 inside accidents.
The little woman was additionally lacking an earring or a stud from her left ear lobe.
A stud earring matching it was discovered by gardaí on the ground of the condominium.
Clumps of hair had been discovered simply contained in the door of the condominium in addition to close to a sofa.
A closely blood stained quilt was additionally discovered on the scene.
Gardaí additionally discovered blood stains within the condominium together with footprints in blood and a drag-mark in blood.
Det Garda Dennehy mentioned that there was proof of a disturbance within the kitchen of the property.
Blood-stained grownup leggings in a black floral sample had been later found in a downstairs bed room.
Gardaí additionally discovered a suspected hashish joint within the condominium.
In cross-examination with defence counsel Brendan Grehan SC, Detective Dennehy mentioned it was an uncommon scene.
“It was a wierd scene to look at and interpret, particularly the lounge,” he mentioned.
“It was fairly troublesome to interpret what occurred. There was loads of blood within the kitchen. (However) other than the quilt there was no blood in the lounge.”
Detective Garda Eoghain O’Callaghan, who was known as to the Elderwood complicated shortly after 5am when Santina was discovered critically injured, mentioned he needed to act to calm tensions between Santina’s father, Michael Cawley, and his then-girlfriend, Karen Harrington.
“Michael Cawley got here as much as her (Karen Harrington) and shouted in her face,” Det Gda O’Callaghan mentioned.
“(He shouted) you killed my child – you monster.”
Det Gda O’Callaghan mentioned he famous a odor of alcohol from each Mr Cawley and the defendant.
Each had been very distressed at totally different instances outdoors the Elderwood complicated.
He mentioned that Karen Harrington was cautioned as she stood outdoors.
“(She mentioned) she had returned to No 26 (after 1.30am) by herself,” the detective garda mentioned.
“Michael Cawley (later) arrived with the kid asleep in his arms.
“She (the defendant) was woken up by Michael Cawley shouting that the kid was useless (5am).
“She mentioned she was asleep for the remainder of the evening. She mentioned she was woken up by Michael Cawley shouting that the kid was useless and he or she ran out of the condominium.”
Det Gda O’Callaghan famous that Mr Cawley had shouted on the defendant that she was “a monster.”
He mentioned that Karen Harrington, who was flanked by a feminine pal, replied to him: “I did yeah, I did yeah” in a sarcastic tone.
The garda agreed with defence counsel Brendan Grehan SC that her sarcastic tone steered that the alternative was in reality the case.
Gardaí moved Mr Cawley and the defendant away from one another to calm tensions – and away from paramedics who had been desperately attempting to save lots of the little woman.
Cork Fireplace Brigade lead fireman Pat Hayes mentioned he famous blood spatters on the kitchen flooring of No 26 the place Santina was discovered.
He additionally famous a nappy in an undergarment close to to the soiled quilt the place the kid was present in important situation.
He was approached by Mr Cawley, whom he didn’t know, and was requested: “Are you able to inform me, is my baby alive or not?”
“I instructed him he needed to relax – he was being very aggressive. I mentioned now we have a pulse and we’re doing the most effective we are able to.”
He confirmed that Mr Cawley needed to journey within the ambulance along with his daughter to CUH was not permitted to take action.
Mr Hayes mentioned he provided to seek the advice of with Gardaí about them bringing Mr Cawley to the hospital.
“He was behaving in a really aggressive method,” he mentioned.
Minutes later, he mentioned Mr Cawley seen two females close to the Elderwood complicated, one in all whom was Karen Harrington.
“(Mr Cawley mentioned) That is the folks try to be – that is your suspect there,” Mr Hayes mentioned.
Mr Hayes mentioned that when he went into the condominium he seen an toddler woman mendacity bare on a unclean quilt.
Different paramedics mentioned the quilt was soiled and smelled strongly of urine.
“Considered one of her legs was distorted and there was blood round her mouth and nostril. There have been bruises on her arms,” Mr Hayes mentioned.
“The scene was frantic with everybody (Gardaí, fireplace brigade and paramedics) attempting to save lots of the kid.”
The trial continues.